| 
|
|
|
Project
Areas
-
•
-
•
-
•
-
•
-
•
-
•
-
•

|
|
|
UVI-CES
Erosion & Sediment Control Demonstration Project
|
Project Report
1997 - 1999
TASK
1: VEGETATIVE STABILIZATION DEMONSTRATIONS
CES Demonstration Garden Plots
Native
and naturalized ground covers that can be used to stabilize
soils on varying slopes were planted at the UVI St. Thomas Cooperative
Extension Service Demonstration Garden beginning in September
1997. In the first trial planting, staff planted native species
talinum (Talinum triangulare), inch plant (Callisia repens),
spider lily (Hymenocallis caribea) and Pepperomia magnifolia,
as well as exotics species sunrose (Portulaca sp.) and ground
orchid (Callisia fragrans). A row of vetiver grass (Vetiveria
zizanioides) was also planted along the bottom of the slope
to form a living terrace as sediment builds up behind the grass.
Growth, soil cover and survival rates were
evaluated during a six-month period. With occasional watering,
talinum, inch plant, spider lily, ground orchid and vetiver
were all easily propagated. Sunrose did not propagate well
and died during the dry period. Talinum and inch plant provided
the greatest percentage of ground cover within six months.
Ground orchid did not provide sufficient ground cover and
was taken over by weeds. Native plants out-performed exotics
(with the exception of vetiver) in this trial.
A second
trial was initiated in May 1999. Exotic plants lantana (Lantana
sp.), mini rhoeo (Rhoeo sp.), purple queen (Tradescantia pallida),
wandering jew (Zebrina pendula), blue daze, purslane and "jump-up-and-kiss-me"
(all Portulaca sp.) were planted on cleared slopes (20 - 30%)
above the CES St. Thomas office driveway and parking area.
Growth, soil cover and survival rates are being evaluated
for these plots also.
Hydroseeding Demonstrations
Bahia grass
(Paspalum notatum, a native, drought-tolerant grass species)
was seeded behind the new cafeteria at the UVI St. Croix campus
in January 1998. Bahia grass was used to evaluate whether germination
and establishment rates were quicker than those of bermuda grass
(Cynodon dactylon), which was previously used. It was found
that bahia grass germination and propagation rates were in fact
slower than those of bermuda grass. However, once established,
bahia grass tended to be hardier than bermuda grass.
A
variety of ESC practices were installed during the field day
demonstration sessions of the Practical
Approaches for Effective Erosion & Sediment Control
(ESC) training workshops held May 30, 1998 on St. Thomas and
June 2 on St. Croix. Workshop participants were given installation
instructions during in-class training the day before the field
sessions.
During
the St. Thomas workshop, steep, south-facing slopes at the
Cost-U-Less development site were hydroseeded using bahia,
rye (Lolium perenne) and bermuda grass seeds, cellulose (paper)
fiber hydromulch, and a soil binder. Bermuda grass seed was
also hand-broadcast in a sediment retention pond overflow
swale at the site. On St. Croix, bahia grass was hydroseeded,
along with cellulose fiber hydromulch and a soil binder, and
hand-broadcast at a home/farm site in Estate St. George's
Hill.
Bermuda
grass hand-broadcast at the St. Thomas site germinated well
beneath the straw/coconut fiber mat, but did not become well
established, possibly because it was inhibited by an adjacent
tamarind tree. The bahia and bermuda grass that was hydroseeded
germinated and is becoming well established on the shady slopes.
The grass hydroseeded on unshaded slopes died because the
seedlings did not get enough water to grow after germination
and were burnt by the hot sun.
Bahia
grass hydroseeded at the St. Croix sites was quickly over
grown by guinea grass. However, bahia grass seed that was
hand broadcast and then covered with the excelsior erosion
control mats germinated and propagated well.
Back to top
TASK
2: EROSION CONTROL MAT DEMONSTRATIONS
Erosion
control mats consist of natural or synthetic fibers woven together
to form a mat or blanket, and backed with plastic netting. They
are used to cover bare soils or slopes during construction or
until grass or other plants can become established. We used
different types of mats in this project to determine:
- How
well they prevented erosion,
- How
well they promoted plant growth, and
- How
long they lasted.
Donoe Housing Community
CES and
the VI Housing Authority cooperated to demonstrate the use
and effectiveness of erosion and sediment control blankets/mats
for slope stabilization. Erosion control mats were installed
in November 1997 on disturbed slopes along the road at the
Donoe Housing Community (St. Thomas).
CES purchased
100% straw fiber (S2) and 70% straw/30% coconut fiber mix
(CS2) erosion control mats and staples and provided VIHA grounds
personnel with training on proper installation procedures.
VIHA
grounds personnel prepared the area (cleared brush, removed
debris, stones and stumps, and raked to smooth the slope surface)
and installed the matting along steep (> 60%), stony, droughty
slopes. CS2 mats were used for the steepest sections (specified
for 1:1 slopes up to 75' in length), and S2 mats (specified
for 2:1 slopes up to 75' in length) were used for less steep
sections. Mats were installed around desirable vegetation
(ginger thomas - Tecoma stans, pink cedar - Tabeburia heterophyllo
and bougainvillea - Bougainvillea glabra) that was kept on
the slope during the clearing process. Ground orchid (an exotic
ground cover adapted to steep, stony, droughty slopes) and
ginger thomas (a native bush that was already present at the
site) were planted within the matting to help further stabilize
the soils. CES provided technical assistance, training, and
materials to the Virgin Islands Housing Authority (VIHA),
and continues to work with VIHA and Donoe residents on ESC
projects.
Workshop Demonstration Installations
A 100% coconut
fiber mat was installed as part of the hands-on field demonstration
session at the 1997 V.I. Nonpoint Source (NPS) Pollution Conference
held December 2-3 on St. Croix. The mat was installed on a bare
slope (>30%) behind the UVI cafeteria to show attendees how
ESC mats are used to stabilize steep, bare slopes and to demonstrate
practice installation techniques.
A CS2 erosion control mat was installed during
the St. Thomas ESC training workshop to demonstrate the use
of ESC mats for channel stabilization, proper installation
techniques for the practice, and to evaluate its effectiveness
in promoting grass seed germination, as well as its durability.
The mat was installed in the overflow swale from a sediment
retention pond.
At the St. Croix ESC training workshop, excelsior
(wood fiber) mat and hay mulch were installed on a steep slope
(>45%) at a home/farm site in Estate St. George's Hill (see
photo, page 2). Workshop participants first seeded the cleared
slope with bahia grass seed and then installed excelsior matting
on one segment and hay mulch on an adjoining segment in order
to compare the two practices for erosion control effectiveness
and longevity. 
UVI St. Thomas Music Building
The project
also provided the UVI-St. Thomas Physical Plant with straw erosion
control mats to stabilize the steep, bare slopes (>50%) adjacent
to and behind the new Music Education building. The area was
hand seeded with a fescue (Festuca arundinacea) rye grass mix
and the mats were installed in early February 1999. They are
performing well in stabilizing the slope and promoting vegetation
growth.
Erosion Control Mat Results
All four
varieties of erosion control mat (straw, straw/coconut, coconut,
and excelsior) functioned properly in controlling erosion from
the demonstration sites before breaking down. However, a few
disadvantages were observed. The shallow depth to rock at the
Donoe site made anchoring the matting along the bottom 1/3 of
the slope almost impossible. This condition also made it extremely
difficult to keep the material flat against the slope.
In addition, the mat worked very well at retaining moisture
in the soil, which unfortunately accelerated the rate of vegetation
by undesirable weedy species (guinea grass and tan tan).
The mats installed at all sites have biodegraded
significantly. The straw/coconut fiber (CS2) mat has been
the most durable, taking approximately 6 months to disintegrate,
whereas the excelsior mat installed on St. Croix completely
disintegrated after only 2 ½ months; this may be partially
due to the high rainfall that occurred during June and July
1998.
Back to top
TASK
3: STRUCTURAL PRACTICES
Silt Fencing
Proper
silt fence installation was demonstrated to trainees during
the St. Croix ESC training workshop. We used rebar in place
of wood stakes to anchor the fence and emphasized the importance
of trenching the material into the soil. Participants dug the
trench for the fencing, placed material and ½" rebar,
and backfilled trench. The silt fence was found to be performing
properly during a site visit July 29, 1998. Approximately 4
to 6" of sediment was observed accumulated behind the fence
with a minimal amount of sediment on the roadway below the fence.
Silt fencing was also was installed at the
CES - St. Thomas Home Demonstration Garden in March 1999 to
prevent soil on the slope above the driveway from eroding
and silting in the driveway. Signs describing the project
and comparing good and bad silt fence installation practices
were produced and the fence is being maintained as a demonstration
of proper installation. The fence is functioning properly
in keeping sediment from flowing off the slope onto the driveway.
Triangular Dikes
A
triangular dike was also installed during the St. Croix ESC
training workshop to demonstrate how it can be used as a check
dam in a swale leading to a drainage culvert. Participants
cleared the area for the dike, anchored it in, and backfilled
soil and rock on top of dike flaps to hold it in place. During
a follow-up site visit on June 29, 1998, the triangular dike
was found to be functioning properly, with approximately one
inch of sediment observed accumulated behind the dike. Triangular
dikes were also used on the St. Thomas CES parking lot during
excavation and grass germination to prevent soil from washing
off the driveway and into the road (see below).
Porous Paving
Two
alternative paving practices using webbed cellular confinement
material (GeoWeb®) and interlocking plastic blocks (GeoBlock®)
are on display at the St. Thomas CES parking lot and driveway.
These porous materials are more environmentally friendly foundations
for low-use roads and parking areas. Six-inch plastic web cellular
confinement material (GeoWeb®) was installed on the UVI-CES
St. Thomas office driveway and 2" plastic blocks (GeoBlock®)
were installed on the CES office parking lot. These practices
were installed to:
- Control
erosion and flooding problems experienced at the site;
- To
demonstrate the use of porous paving systems, as compared
to gravel or bare soil, to reduce stormwater runoff and
erosion; and
- To
evaluate the materials' durability under VI conditions.
CES
staff prepared the CES Home Demonstration Garden (removed weeds,
cut back invasive bush, dug out and removed diseased trees)
prior to the demonstration. Staff worked with a UVI architect
to map out the St. Thomas CES office driveway and parking lot
demonstration sites. The parking lot and driveway were then
excavated and graded for the demonstration; the lot was also
rolled with a vibrating roller to smooth it.
Installation occurred in early February 1999
by CES staff with assistance from crew and the product's distributor
in Puerto Rico. The web installation in the driveway was conducted
as part of a hands-on workshop for thirty-seven (37) attendees.
Participants were shown a video describing the use and proper
installation of the material, and then participated in installing
the webbing. Each 20' long section of the GeoWeb® was
stretched and anchored (using j-bars along the sides and end
pieces) down the driveway, and the sections were joined with
staples. The webs were then filled (by backhoe) with crushed
stone and soil, and the stone and soil was rolled with a vibrating
roller to enhance compaction.
CES
staff installed the GeoBlocks® in the parking lot the
following week. The blocks were laid flat and interlocked,
with the edges anchored using j-bars. Uneven edges were cut
using a saw to provide more level coverage. A backhoe was
used to filled the blocks with topsoil, the soil was raked
level by hand, and stones were removed. The parking lot was
then seeded with a mix of bermuda, rye and bahia grasses and
covered with straw erosion control mats to hold in moisture
and prevent birds from eating the grass seed.
The parking
lot was watered and fertilized to promote faster grass germination
and establishment. Parking was prohibited on the lot for three
(3) months so that the grass could become well established.
Heavy use of the drive portion of the lot has damaged some
of the grass, but the grass in the parking areas along the
side is holding up well.
Back to top
TASK
4: PUBLIC OUTREACH
VICES and
VICD have provided and will continue to provide public education
and outreach on erosion and sediment control in the Virgin Islands
throughout the duration of the project and beyond.
-
A project report was presented detailing the completed portion
of the first phase of the project (vegetation and erosion
control matting stabilization demonstrations) at the 1997
V.I. Nonpoint Source Pollution Conference.
-
Practice installation demonstrations were carried out at
the 1997 NPS Conference (50 attendees), the January 1998
St. Croix Hydroseeding Certification Workshop (30 attendees),
the Practical Approaches for
Effective Erosion & Sediment Control
training workshops held May 28 - 29 and June 2 - 3, 1998
on St. Thomas and St. Croix (34 attendees), and the Porous
Paving demonstration
held February 5, 1999 (37 attendees). Participants included
architects, engineers, draftsmen, contractors and regulators
(see above).
-
Articles on the project, highlighting the Donoe Housing
Community erosion control mat demonstration and the installations
performed during the Practical
Approaches for Erosion & Sediment Control Workshop,
appeared in the V.I. NPS Update Spring and Summer 1998 Newsletters,
which were distributed to 1100 architects, businesses, contractors,
draftsmen, engineers, policy-makers, regulators, and other
interested members of the general public.
-
This web page linked to the UVI-CES home page was developed
and uploaded on the UVI-CES website outlining the objectives
and accomplishments of the project http://rps.uvi.edu/CES/ESCdemo.htm.

- Photographic
and video records have been kept of the various stages of
the project and project activities for use at DPNR/VICD/VICES
workshops and conferences.
- Signs
designating the demonstration project were installed at
the Donoe Housing Community demonstration site, the CES
Home Demonstration Garden, and the CES St. Thomas driveway/parking lot
demonstration.
- An
erosion control model was built for use at the CES Home
Demonstration Garden for workshops and tours and at fairs
and conferences.
-
A presentation entitled "Promoting
Erosion & Sediment Control in the U.S. Virgin Islands"
was delivered at both the International Erosion Control
Association's Conference and Trade Show held February 21-26,
1999 in Nashville, Tennessee (the paper was also published
in the conference proceedings) and at the USDA-NRCS Caribbean
Area district conservationist's annual meeting, held July
20 - 22, Dorado, PR.
- A
brochure, targeted to the general public, was developed
outlining the goals and highlights of the project demonstrations
(various practices installed and results observed).
- The
project was advertised through radio shows and public service
announcements.
- Tours
of project sites will continue to be conducted for government
personnel, architects, engineers, developers, contractors
and the general public.
- A
60-second public service announcement for television, utilizing
film footage taken during demonstration installations, and
new radio PSAs is being developed.
Back to top
CONCLUSIONS
Vegetation
Native
plants
out-performed exotics (with the exception of vetiver) in terms
of propagation rate and rate of ground coverage. This is primarily
because native species are more adapted to varying weather conditions
and soil types than most exotic plant species.
Inch plant
is very successful at covering steep, droughty, rocky slopes.
Talinum is very successful
in covering bare soils ranging from moist to dry conditions.
These species will work well in reducing erosion from small
storm events, but neither of these species has a thick root
system (such as bermuda, bahia, hurricane or carpet grass)
or deep root system that can prevent mass wasting (landslides)
that may occur during large storms or hurricanes.
Vetiver
is easily propagated from cuttings. The first method of propagation
involved removing sections from a parent plant (root and leaf
material), trimming excess roots (leaving only 3") and (leaving
4" of leaf). "Plugs" were then planted directly in the demonstration
plot and watered daily. This first planting took 4-5 weeks
to develop new shoots. However, we discovered a faster, more
reliable method of propagation: materials were prepared as
before but then rooted in water for about 4 days (until new
root material was observed). The plugs were then transplanted
into the demonstration plots. This second planting took 2
weeks to develop new shoots. Using this method of propagation,
no mortality occurred, whereas the previous method resulted
in approximately 20% plant mortality.
Hydroseeding
can
be a very effective erosion control practice, but only if
sufficient moisture is available for grass germination and
propagation. This means that bare soils should be seeded either
during the rainy season or else supplemental water must be
provided to ensure success. Success rates increase in areas
where shade is present, particularly on north-facing slopes,
and if a mulch is provided.
Erosion Control Matting
Erosion
control mats are an effective erosion control practice. They
work very well in stabilizing steep slopes and conserve moisture
in the soil, promoting plant growth to further stabilize slopes.
However, they are not appropriate for very stony soils or slopes
with rock outcrops, because the presence of stone and rock prevents
stapling of the material.
Straw mats (100%) are specified for
use on 2:1 (25%) slopes up to 75' in length, but were observed
to prevent erosion on shorter slopes up to 1:1 (50%) steepness.
Straw (70%)/coconut (30%) fiber mats are specified
for use on 1:1 slopes up to 75' in length, and were observed
to perform well on even steeper slopes (~60%) that were shorter
in length (no greater than 50'). Excelsior fiber mats
were not sufficiently durable under demonstration conditions.
Silt Fences
Silt fences
can be an effective sediment control practice if installed properly.
Fences not trenched into the soil will fail. Fences installed
at the base of steep slopes will also fail if reinforcement,
in the form of plastic or steel mesh backing, is not provided.
Wood stakes should only be used in flat, non-stony soils - many
contractors have reported installing silt fences improperly
because wood stakes either can't be pounded into the soil or
break during the attempt. Fences installed in all other areas
should utilize rebar stakes. It is important to keep in mind
that by design, the maximum length of slope that a reinforced
silt fence can collect and hold stormwater from decreases in
direct proportion to slope steepness. For example, a reinforced
silt fence on a 5% slope can treat a maximum slope length of
250 feet, whereas the same fence on a 25% slope can only treat
a slope length of 55 feet.
Triangular Dikes
Triangular
dikes work well in removing sediment from gradual slopes in
small drainage areas (one (1) acre or less). They also work
well as check dams in gradual swales. This practice was not
tested for steep slopes or swales with high runoff velocities.
Porous Paving Systems
Webbed
cellular confinement systems
work very well in reducing erosion and stormwater runoff from
gradual driveways and low-use roads. For these uses, it is necessary
for rock (gravel or crusher run) to be used as fill material
instead of soil, in order to provide sufficient load support
(especially if filter fabric is not placed below the webbing
and fill material).
Grassed
block/grid cellular confinement systems can work well
in controlling erosion and stormwater on fairly level, low-use
traffic areas, such as emergency access areas, driveways or
parking lots. For higher or heavier used parking areas, gravel
fill would be more appropriate, as continual vehicular traffic
damages the grass base. Some disadvantages for use in the
V.I. have been observed on the grassed demonstration system.
First, the subsurface must be completely level for the blocks
to lay properly. Secondly, for a grassed parking area that
requires soil fill, the blocks should be filled by hand in
order to avoid over-filling with soil. Over-filling reduces
the blocks ability to protect grasses planted within the system
so that continual traffic will damage the sod.
CES
will continue to maintain and install erosion and sediment
control practices to promote pollution prevention in the territory.
For more information on erosion and sediment control, contact
the UVI Cooperative Extension Service at (340) 692-4080 on
St. Croix or (340) 693-1080 on St. Thomas. |
|
| The
mission of the University of the Virgin Islands Cooperative Extension
Service is to advance knowledge for agriculture, the environment,
human health and well being, and communities. |
|
| |
| The
University of the Virgin Islands is an equal opportunity provider
and employer. |
| page
last modified
February 6, 2004
|
|
|
|